You marry Non. One day, Eli goes up to you and asks if he could court you. How will you tell him you're married?

Good grief, this is hard. D:

But thoroughly reflecting on the question (naks! Binibining Pilipinas / Miss Universe much?) makes me realize this: If I married Non, then something must have happened between Eli and I, that led to some sort of separation, whether mutual or not, and must have affected me so much that I did not want to return to him.

But I'm a woman of second chances. Perhaps I did give Eli another chance, but somehow that didn't work out. I probably ended up marrying Non because he's really that much of a good person and all that shebang. There must have been something in him that Eli was not able to fulfill, and that could have been why I chose Non over Eli.

*audience is bewildered, then bursts into applause* :))

(Sorry! My childhood beauty queen dreams kind of peeked right there :p)

Ask, and you shall get answers. They won't always make sense, though. :D